Singer Scott Leaves, and the World Grieves...Well Not Really

Another American Idol singer packs up his Microphone

Well, the nice guy goes home, and even though we're sad to see him go, this is after all a competitive talent show and there is just one winner, or is there?

Arizona native, Scott McKintyre, did a good job and inspired millions of people across the nation because he stood on the stage happy, smiling, and undaunted by his visual impairment. But, this competition was about singing and Scott was simply not the best. I think many viewers have felt this way for weeks, and according to the poll here on Audition Portal's blog, our readers had made that clear weeks ago. Scott, Anoop Desai, and Lil Rounds were on the stools this week and in the wake of Scott's performance on Tuesday, it was clear he was the one that would be going home. Scott was the viewers choice to be sent home and now with only minutes left, he had to sing for his life, one last time so the judges could decide whether he was worth the only save their allowed to use.

Last night's show was interlaced with a naughty performance by Flo Rida, and former Idol, Kelly Pickler, who's performance was about as pitchy as one could expect for a performer running around on stage, out of breath. Flo Rida's "Right Round" was unedited and most likely the least family-friendly performance American Idol has had on the show. The song, depending on how you decipher it, is either about oral sex or a stripper sliding down a pole. Either way, Mrs. Cleaver was rolling in her grave.

With the time running out, Cowell looked at the bottom three and said, "I don't think it mattered before, but I think this is the first week where it probably does matter," adding that the judges would consider saving one of the others in danger of getting the boot.

It's clear that Scott's infectious smile got him through most vote-offs when his performances were less than stellar. When it came time to announcing his fate, Scott continued his endearing smile and took it like a man. "I really, really like you, Scott," Cowell said. I'm looking over there, and I think there's a bunch of talented singers, so this decision isn't just based on you. It's whether I think somebody, or we think somebody, is more talented over there." This was probably one of Simon's most sensitive and well-phrased assessments, as barely a "boo" was heard while he spoke.

It was clear that the audience, while torn emotionally, felt the same exact way.

With seconds left in the show, Seacrest and ensemble gave MacIntyre a hug for his farewell, with Paula commenting, "You've been an inspiration to the entire world through your commitment, through your talent. And we all watch 'American Idol' so that we as an audience get to witness unique and gifted artists as you, Scott. ... You are one classy gentleman. God bless you, we love you."

While Scott technically goes home and is off the show, he does get to tour the country this summer with the final 10 contestants. Most likely, we'll still see Scott here and there, and don't be surprised if he lands a record deal. While there may be one "Idol" winner, there are many when you factor in the luminous exposure all of these kids have gotten.

Next week, get ready as Jennifer Hudson, the Oscar-winning powerhouse returns to the show.

Be sure to get your American Idol dose right here on Audition Portal's blog. Follow us, get news, updates, interviews and polls, as the competition get's more intense!

Jared Lifeson
www.auditionportal.com